This easy vegetarian stuffing recipe features all of the classic flavors of your favorite stuffing recipe, but in a vegetarian version everyone around your holiday dinner table will love.
Coming up on my first Thanksgiving after becoming a vegetarian, I remember fielding loads of questions about whether or not I’d eat turkey on Thanksgiving.
Honestly, I had to laugh! I mean, no guys, vegetarians don’t eat turkey. Besides, doesn’t everyone agree that the sides are the best part of the Thanksgiving feast anyway?!
Traditionally my mom always hosted Thanksgiving and because she’s awesome, she’d always makes sure I had plenty to eat, including adapting her incredible homemade stuffing recipe to suit my “please don’t pour melted turkey all over my stuffing” needs.
What has resulted after nearly 15 years of tweaking is this – the world’s best vegetarian stuffing recipe. It has all the requisite flavors of sage and celery, but you know, with none of the melted turkey bits.
I assure you, this recipe is masterful and full of a mother’s careful attention to flavor. Luckily for all of us, she make careful notes the last time she made it so I can share it with all of you.
Even if you aren’t vegetarian, you will go crazy over this stuffing. Cross my heart.
What Is in Vegetarian Stuffing?
To make this vegetarian stuffing recipe, you will need:
- Vegetable stock – Make sure to use vegetable stock for this recipe, store bought or homemade. Using chicken, beef or any other meat-based stock will alter this recipe to no longer be vegetarian.
- Melted butter – I prefer using salted butter, but unsalted will also work for this recipe.
- Granny Smith apple – Granny Smith apple adds a touch of the sweet tartness that stuffing needs.
- Celery – Celery is a classic stuffing ingredient so don’t skip it!
- Onion – I generally use white, yellow or sweet onions. They’ll all work well.
- Black pepper – Season the stuffing mixture well with your favorite black pepper.
- Salt – I like using a coarse ground sea salt for this recipe, but any kosher salt or sea salt will do.
- Celery seed – Boost the celery flavor with the addition of celery seed.
- Ground sage – Sage is one of those traditional seasonings that adds so much to stuffing.
- Poultry seasoning – The name is a bit misleading here as this is a seasoning blend that adds a bunch of flavor, but is actually vegetarian.
- Eggs – Eggs help to bind the stuffing mixture together and also provide moisture so it’s not too dried out.
- Raisins – This can be an area of debate, but I think dried fruit like raisins add so much flavor to stuffing.
- Dried cranberries – See above. Dried cranberries are seriously delicious in this stuffing recipe.
- Bread – My mom has always used a mixture of whole wheat and Italian bread. It’s ok if it’s stale or a little dried out.
How to Make Vegetarian Stuffing
If we’re being super technical, it’s a bit misleading to call this recipe “stuffing” since it’s never stuffed into anything but a baking dish or lidded casserole dish.
In other words, don’t stuff your bird with this stuffing or you’ve missed the whole point, ya know?
To that end, start by preheating your oven to 350° F and then prepare a large casserole dish by greasing it lightly with nonstick cooking spray. You can make this recipe work with whatever size dish you happen to have.
Combine all ingredients except for the veggie stock and butter in a large mixing bowl and use your hands to mix well.
Once combined, pour the veggie stock and butter over top and use your hands to mix well again.
The resulting mixture will be very moist and somewhat sticky. That’s when you know it’s perfect!
Spoon it into your casserole dish and bake, covered, for approximately 30 minutes. Remove the lid and bake for an additional 15 minutes.
When the stuffing is down it will be lightly golden brown on the top and around the edges.
If you don’t have a covered casserole dish, a glass baking dish covered with aluminum foil will also work. You may need to adjust baking times if your dish is more shallow.
What Kind of Bread Do You Use for Vegetarian Stuffing?
At the end of the day, you can basically use whatever bread you can get your hands on, or whatever bread is going stale in your house to make this vegetarian stuffing recipe.
My mom always uses a combination of whole wheat and Italian breads, because she prefers the texture it gives the stuffing. You could also use sourdough or plain white sandwich bread.
This recipe calls for 1/2 loaf of sourdough bread and 1/2 loaf of whole wheat bread, referencing standard sandwich bread sized loaves.
When you rip it into chunks it should roughly equal about 6 cups very loosely packed. It’s ok if you have a bit more than that!
What Kind of Stock Do You Use in Vegetarian Stuffing?
You’ll need to use vegetable stock when making vegetarian stuffing in order to make it truly vegetarian. Many brands carry delicious veggie stocks that work great for stuffing.
My mom traditionally makes homemade vegetable stock that she then uses to make stuffing. I’ve included her recipe and notes below if you’d like to go that route.
Either way will be super delicious!
How to Make Homemade Vegetable Stock
To make homemade vegetable stock, you’ll need the following ingredients:
- 1 large celery stalk plus 3 celery stalk tops
- 2 large carrots
- 1 medium onion
- 1 green bell pepper
- 8 – 10 whole black peppercorns
- pinch of sea salt
- 2 bay leaves
- 6 sage leaves
- ½ gallon of water
- 1 tablespoon rosemary
- 1 tablespoon parsley
Steps for making homemade vegetable broth:
- Cut all of the veggies into large chunks and place in the bottom of a stock pot.
- Top with approximately ½ gallon of water.
- Add herbs and spices and bring to a low boil over medium-high heat.
- Reduce heat to a simmer and cover, simmering for 1 – 2 hours.
- Remove from the heat and strain off the herbs, spices and veggies, preserving the liquid.
What to Serve with Homemade Vegetarian Stuffing
Here are a few more of my favorite vegetarian side dishes and desserts, all of which perfectly complement my mom’s vegetarian stuffing recipe:
- Scalloped sweet potatoes
- Mini green bean casserole puffs
- Mulled apple cider
- Butternut squash goat cheese crostini
- Hazelnut cake with apple buttercream
- Salted caramel pumpkin cheesecake parfaits
Yield: 8 Prep Time: 20 minutes Cook Time: 45 minutes Total Time: 1 hour 5 minutes This easy vegetarian stuffing recipe features all of the classic flavors of your favorite stuffing recipe, but in a vegetarian version everyone around your holiday dinner table will love. If you don’t have a covered casserole dish, a glass baking dish covered with aluminumfoil will also work. You may need to adjust baking times if your dish is more shallow.
Ingredients
Instructions
Notes
[Photos by Alice G. Patterson for The Sweetest Occasion.]
