Best Ever Christmas Cinnamon Pickles Recipe! - Me and My Captain (2024)

I know what you are thinking….

HOW on earth can we think about the task of making homemade pickles when we just got over Thanksgiving!!!

Best Ever Christmas Cinnamon Pickles Recipe! - Me and My Captain (1)I know how you are feeling.

Me too!

Thanksgiving can be a lot of work if you are hosting…

….even if you are not hosting, just about any family event can be exhausting.

That is why I envy the stamina of the Black Friday shoppers the day after Thanksgiving.

I hope your Thanksgiving was great and I have to confess that our Thanksgiving dinner was successful for Me and My Captain.

Yummy food and I love the left overs.

This recipe always receives a lot of requests.

I absolutely love them… if you have never tried them, you must.

If your garden cucumbers are not ready yet…which I suspect they are not, one can go to a farmers market or super market and pick up lovely cucumbers.

Cinnamon Pickles don’t have to be for Christmas only…but they certainly add to your Christmas tablescape!

First off, I love to can and preserve foods. It is just comfort for me.

These Cinnamon Pickles are so easy to make and you can use any size cucumber.

Most people prefer the small pickling cucumbers because they don’t get tough but any size will work.

These are so pretty to set out on your Christmas Dinner table and they taste so yummy!

This recipe has been in my recipe file for years and years and I remember my grandmother making these for Christmas as they are so bright red from the cinnamon and red hots.

They almost look like glass and are almost too pretty to eat.

I have made these from time to time, but I have to tell you they do have a process that takes some time…actually 4 days.

But Stop!!!

Before you turn away and say, too much work for my busy days…let me say that there is only one small task each day, and then you return to your regularly scheduled program, ignoring the pickles.

Let me show you the easy steps.

First, you will need cucumbers which you will peel and seed.

This is relatively easy, just use a spoon to scrape out the seeds of the cucumber much like you would acantaloupe.

Then you cut into strips and then cubes.

You will need pickling lime and alum which can be found in your supermarket.

After cutting into cubes (or you can leave the long strips)….you add about 8 quarts of cold water into a glass bowl along with the lime…then add the cucumbers.

Let the cucumbers set in the lime water for 24 hours. (I use an old crock, but you can use any large container)

The next day (day 2) drain the lime water off and discard.

Wash the cucumbers and cover again with cold water and ice and soak for about 4 hours.

Drain and rinse again.

Then you make your brine mixture…add your cucumbers and simmer.

Drain them and make the syrup and add to the cucumbers and simmer some more.

Then you let the cucumbers stand overnight.

Day 3…drain the syrup from the cucumbers and reheat the syrup, and pour back over the cucumbers.

Day 4 Repeat the same process.

On Day 5….prepare the jars, drain off the syrup and save….pack the cucumbers into the jars…add the syrup and process.

And there you have it!

How simple was that?

Enjoy your Cinnamon Pickles!

I have to admit…we have been enjoying these pickles for a couple months now.

I hope there is a jar or two left for Christmas Dinner….:)

My dear readers, Have you made pickles?

Best Ever Christmas Cinnamon Pickles Recipe! - Me and My Captain (8)

Christmas Cinnamon Pickles

A wonderful treat of red, cinnamon-ey cubes of sweetness in a pickle. This recipe is so old…I can not even imagine the original date…It has been handed down generation to generation. It is not difficult to make…just a few extra steps over a period of 4 days, but believe me when I tell you they are simply delicious.

Write a review

Print

Ingredients

  1. Cucumbers (about 32 medium size, peeled and seeded and cut into 1 inch cubes)
  2. 2 cups of lime
  3. 8 1/2 quarts of water
  4. 1 cup vinegar
  5. 1 ounce of red food coloring
  6. 1 tablespoon alum
  7. 4 cups vinegar
  8. 4 cups water
  9. 15 cups sugar
  10. 8 cinnamon sticks
  11. 1 pkg of red hots (about 1 cup)

First day

  1. Combine cucumber cubes, lime, and water and let set at room temperature over night (at least 24 hours) stirring occasionally.
  2. Drain and rinse and soak 3 additional hours in clear water and drain.
  3. Mix 1 cup of the vinegar, red food coloring, and alum.
  4. Place the cucumber cubes in large stockpot and cover with water.
  5. Add the above food coloring mixture and simmer for 2 hours
  6. Drain and discard all the liquid
  7. To the stockpot, add the 4 cups of vinegar, 4 cups of water, sugar, cinnamon sticks, and red hots. Bring to a boil, stirring occasionally. (You will use this mixture to pour over the cucumber cubes everyday for 3 days)
  8. I place my cucumber cubes in an old crock that I have had for many years…but you can use any large container you may have.
  9. After bringing the red hot mixture to a boil, I pour the mixture over the cucumber cubes in my crock. Cover with cheesecloth and let set in a cool place for 24 hours.
  10. The next day, pour off the liquid from the cucumber cubes and into a saucepan. Reheat to boiling.
  11. Pour the liquid over the drained cucumber cubes, cover and repeat the process for two more days (3 days total)
  12. On the 4th day, place the cucumber cubes and the syrup liquid into a large stockpot and boil the entire combined mixture for about 5 minutes.
  13. Ladle the cucumbers into sterilized jars (and lids), adding enough syrup to each jar to keep cucumber cubes in liquid.
  14. Place sealed jars in a “canner” (or stockpot of boiling water) and process for 20 minutes.

Notes

  1. I use quart jars as these cinnamon pickles do not last long once opened. They are that good and well worth the extra effort it takes to make.
  2. This recipe makes about 7 quarts of the cinnamon pickles…but you may use pint jars if you prefer.
Best Ever Christmas Cinnamon Pickles Recipe! - Me and My Captain (2024)

FAQs

What are Christmas pickles made of? ›

Stir together sugar, remaining 2 cups vinegar, 2 cups water, red hot candies, and cinnamon sticks in a saucepan over medium heat until sugar and candies dissolve. Pour over warm cucumbers. Cover and let sit for 8 hours to overnight. Pack pickles into hot, sterilized pint jars, filling to within 1/4 inch of the top.

How to make stickle pickles? ›

directions
  1. Use 6-8 medium cucumbers. Cut into sticks. Pour boiling water over them and let stand 5 hours. Drain and pack into jars.
  2. Boil solution for 5 minutes Pour over cucumbers in the jars. Put on top and screw band tight. Process in boiling water 5 minutes.

Where did pickles originate? ›

Pickles have a very long history and are found across all cultures. The earliest known examples are cucumbers that are known to have been pickled some time around 2030 BC in Mesopotamia, when inhabitants from northern India brought cucumber seeds to the Tigris valley.

What the heck is a Christmas pickle? ›

In the tradition, an ornamental pickle is placed on a Christmas tree as one of the Christmas decorations. On Christmas morning, the first person to find the pickle on the tree would receive an extra present from Santa Claus or would be said to have a year of good fortune.

What is the name of the Christmas pickle? ›

Most people are under the impression that ye olde Christmas Pickle is a German tradition. Its name alone seems like a pretty dead giveaway, doesn't it? Well, according to The New York Times, the Weihnachtsgurke is all but unknown in Germany. A German polling agency found that 91% of people had never even heard of it.

What is the secret of pickles? ›

Here are 10 tips for crunchy pickles:
  • Choose Freshly Harvested Cucumbers. As soon as cucumbers are picked, the softening process begins. ...
  • Use the Right Cucumber Varieties. ...
  • Cut off the Ends of Cucumbers. ...
  • Soak Cucumbers in Ice Water. ...
  • Use Calcium Chloride. ...
  • Add a Source of Tannin. ...
  • Use Enough Salt. ...
  • Don't Add Bacteria.

What is the healthiest pickles to eat? ›

“The pickles that are beneficial for your gut health are the fermented ones, made by brining them in salt rather than vinegar,” says Dr. Oppezzo. “While vinegar pickling is a common method, true fermentation in brine enriches them with beneficial probiotics for your gut.

Why do you put turmeric in pickles? ›

Turmeric is a healthy spice, since it contains antioxidants and is thought to help with inflammation and other concerns. This is great, but turmeric also has a wonderful earthy flavor and adds a pretty yellow color to the pickles. It is potent, so a little bit of turmeric goes a long way.

What are the two main ingredients needed to pickle something? ›

The classic ratio is super easy to remember and is easily scale-able depending on how many pickles you're making. It's 100% vinegar, 50% water, 25% sugar and 12.5% kosher salt by weight.

Which vinegar for pickling? ›

Most pickle recipes call for distilled white vinegar. This is the clear, colorless vinegar made by fermenting grains. It has a mellow aroma, tart acid flavor and does not affect the color of light-colored vegetables or fruits.

How much vinegar do you use for pickling? ›

The basic ratio for quick pickles is 1:1 vinegar to water, and includes some combination of salt and sugar. Another ratio that is commonly followed is the 3:2:1 method, using three parts vinegar, two parts water, and 1 part sugar.

Why do pickle jars not say pickle? ›

Olive all use the term on their websites, in advertisem*nts, and in the product descriptions of their pickle varieties. When asked why the word isn't on the front of the jars, all three companies provided nearly the same answer: They feel the word “pickle” isn't necessary on pickles packaged in clear glass containers.

What country eats the most pickles? ›

Germans eat the most pickles in the world. The Netherlands is number three. Americans eat their share of pickles.

What state eats the most pickles? ›

The state that loves pickles the most is Maine, followed by Vermont, North Dakota, South Dakota, and West Virginia, respectively. The state that dislikes pickles the most is Hawaii, with Nevada and Florida a close second and third. It's safe to say that pickles have won over the hearts and taste buds of many.

What is the origin of the Christmas pickle? ›

For years, people believed that the Christmas pickle tradition was passed down through the generations from Old World Germany. Other people believe the pickle is in honor of an American Civil War soldier who was saved from starvation on Christmas Eve by eating a pickle.

Where did the German Christmas pickle come from? ›

In some stories, the pickle-hiding game is a centuries-old tradition from Germany that has been passed down through the generations. In others, a captured German-American soldier was saved from starvation on Christmas Eve during the Civil War by eating a pickle.

Why do Germans have a pickle at Christmas? ›

The guard took pity on him and found a pickle for John Lower. According to family legend, John said that the pickle – by the grace of God – gave him the mental and physical strength to live on. Once he was reunited with his family he began a tradition of hiding a pickle on the Christmas tree.

Where did the Christmas pickle ornament come from? ›

The Christmas pickle has vaguely German origins

Around that same time, a story began circulating that German people hung a pickle on their tree as the last ornament. The first child to find the pickle got to open an extra present.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Tish Haag

Last Updated:

Views: 5634

Rating: 4.7 / 5 (67 voted)

Reviews: 82% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Tish Haag

Birthday: 1999-11-18

Address: 30256 Tara Expressway, Kutchburgh, VT 92892-0078

Phone: +4215847628708

Job: Internal Consulting Engineer

Hobby: Roller skating, Roller skating, Kayaking, Flying, Graffiti, Ghost hunting, scrapbook

Introduction: My name is Tish Haag, I am a excited, delightful, curious, beautiful, agreeable, enchanting, fancy person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.